Forum RENO.RO

Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

> Reno.ro - Forum Renault Romania > Alte discutii > Cafenea
2 Pages  1 2 > 
 Reply to this topicStart new topicStart Poll

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

Test comparativ MCV - Roomster

Track this topic | Email this topic | Print this topic | Topic RSS feed
b76bgaarh
post 15 Nov 2007, 10:25
Post #1


Membru autentic


Group: Members
Posts: 9.966
Joined: 5 October 06
From: Bucuresti
http://www.auto-motor-und-sport.de/tests/v...07898_13987.hbs

io zic ca aici nemtii ne-au fentat un pic.........oricum remarca diferenta de 6000 de euroi intre cele doua masini din est......


--------------------
Renault Megane sedan 04/2007 1,5 dci 85 cp ZEFI
Realme GT2 Neo cu here, maps, viamichelin, waze.
User is offlineGalerie FotoPM
Go to the top of the page
+
ssilviu
post 15 Nov 2007, 10:27
Post #2


F1 Man


Group: Members
Posts: 8.043
Joined: 11 June 04
From: Nicaieri
Pacat ca nu au dat raport pret/puncte. Unde Loganul castiga zdrobitor.


--------------------
Renault Megane 2 GPL 2006
Renault Master 2
Renault Clio 4.1 1.2 EDC
Renault Clio 4.2 1.2 EDC
Dacia Dokker 1.6 SCE GPL
Dacia Logan 1.4 GPL
User is offlineGalerie FotoPM
Go to the top of the page
+
dizzy
post 15 Nov 2007, 10:38
Post #3


Work smart not hard!


Group: Members
Posts: 5.128
Joined: 11 February 04
Parerea mea, hac!

MCV:
+ e mai mare
+ are 7 locuri
+ loc in ea sa bagi cosciugu'
+ usi in spate
+ pretul
+ garda mare la sol
+ ampatament
- e mai urata (discutabil)
- motoare diesel mai slabe, lipsa unui motor de 100CP diesel


Roomster
+ arata mai cool
+ motorul diesel 1,9TDI/105CP
+ finisaje si dotari
+ mai scurta deci mai practica in oras
- 5 locuri numai
- scumpa

In opinia mea adevaratul concurent a lui ROOMSTER e Renault Kangoo si nu LGN MCV. Eu personal as alege un Logan MCV cu 5 locuri si cu motor 1.9TDI dar nu se poa.

This post has been edited by dizzy: 15 Nov 2007, 11:21


--------------------
Whirpool ex Dacia Logan - B zzz SXX 2005
Stupidity is a more dangerous enemy of the good than evil.
I have no time to battle egos and small minds.
User is offlineGalerie FotoPM
Go to the top of the page
+
ssilviu
post 15 Nov 2007, 10:40
Post #4


F1 Man


Group: Members
Posts: 8.043
Joined: 11 June 04
From: Nicaieri
QUOTE(dizzy @ 15 Nov 2007, 10:38)
- motoare diesel mai slabe, lipsa unui motor de 100CP diesel


Din cate am inteles eu din linkul ala, au fost testate 1,4 tdi de 80 de cai si 1,5 dci de 85 de cai. A iesit mai prost Loganul la motorizare? Cum asa?

This post has been edited by ssilviu: 15 Nov 2007, 10:40


--------------------
Renault Megane 2 GPL 2006
Renault Master 2
Renault Clio 4.1 1.2 EDC
Renault Clio 4.2 1.2 EDC
Dacia Dokker 1.6 SCE GPL
Dacia Logan 1.4 GPL
User is offlineGalerie FotoPM
Go to the top of the page
+
R19/16v
post 15 Nov 2007, 10:41
Post #5


Oldschool Member


Group: Moderatori
Posts: 13.793
Joined: 2 December 04
From: Ploiesti
QUOTE
+ arata mai cool


parerea ta


--------------------
DS 5H VRSCA Screamin' eagle
Scratch any cynic and you will find a disappointed idealist.
Take what you can - Give nothing back!
User is offlineGalerie FotoPM
Go to the top of the page
+
b76bgaarh
post 15 Nov 2007, 10:43
Post #6


Membru autentic


Group: Members
Posts: 9.966
Joined: 5 October 06
From: Bucuresti
corect e motorul 1,4 de 80 de cai in test........


--------------------
Renault Megane sedan 04/2007 1,5 dci 85 cp ZEFI
Realme GT2 Neo cu here, maps, viamichelin, waze.
User is offlineGalerie FotoPM
Go to the top of the page
+
bear_mc
post 15 Nov 2007, 12:50
Post #7


Half-Life 2 Fan


Group: Members
Posts: 678
Joined: 10 January 05
From: Bucuresti
Mi se pare ca motorul de 1.4 TDI 80Cp de la skoda e in 3 cilindri.


--------------------
Renault Megane II - B-43-ZHY (sau 42) 2005
Confort Expression+clima+jante+vopsea metalizata
(masina lu'tata) for( int i=0, i<68730, i++)
User is offlineGalerie FotoPM
Go to the top of the page
+
IRONICK
post 15 Nov 2007, 12:58
Post #8


-


Group: Members
Posts: 22.771
Joined: 19 April 05
From: Romania
Cum sa zic ... mcv-ul castiga doar la spatiu (mai lunga de fapt) si la pret. In rest este prastie pe langa Romster. Chiar daca design-ul este mai ciudatel.


--------------------
CUGIR Albalux 11 - B-11-LUX 1982
User is offlineGalerie FotoPM
Go to the top of the page
+
Cypher4laguna
post 15 Nov 2007, 14:13
Post #9


Honda Driver


Group: Members
Posts: 931
Joined: 2 November 04
From: Bucuresti
QUOTE(IRONICK @ 15 Nov 2007, 12:58)
In rest este prastie pe langa Romster.
*



parerea ta.... dry.gif


--------------------
Honda Civic & Jazz ex-'06 Logan Laureate 1,5 dci
User is offlineGalerie FotoPM
Go to the top of the page
+
2dor
post 15 Nov 2007, 14:32
Post #10


Desi nu pare, acum sunt fan iPhone


Group: Members
Posts: 2.827
Joined: 14 April 06
From: Bucuresti
Bine ca acum am ajuns sa comparam Skoda cu Dacia. radmasa.gif


--------------------
Ford Mondeo Vignale Hybrid 2018
Be nimble as a greyhound, as tough as leather, as hard as Krupp steel and so you shall be the German warrior incarnate.
User is offlineGalerie FotoPM
Go to the top of the page
+
IRONICK
post 15 Nov 2007, 14:41
Post #11


-


Group: Members
Posts: 22.771
Joined: 19 April 05
From: Romania
Cypher4laguna, remarca asta de unde izvoraste ? Probabil dintr-un profund studiu ...
Explica-mi atunci te rog diferentele dintre solutile tehnice aplicate pe ambele masini. Dar o iei asa frumos ... detalii exterioare, post de conducere, plansa de bord, parte fata (scaune, usi cu sistem de izolare, balamale si inchidere), parte spate, motor (suspensie motor, cadru, bileta antirotire, etc..), esapament, legatura cu solul (adica ... punte fata, punte spate), sistem de franare, insonorizare, ...

This post has been edited by IRONICK: 15 Nov 2007, 15:00


--------------------
CUGIR Albalux 11 - B-11-LUX 1982
User is offlineGalerie FotoPM
Go to the top of the page
+
Amedeus
post 15 Nov 2007, 14:47
Post #12


Membru cu Logan


Group: Members
Posts: 1.907
Joined: 13 December 04
From: TM
QUOTE(2dor @ 15 Nov 2007, 15:32)
Bine ca acum am ajuns sa comparam Skoda cu Dacia. radmasa.gif
*



Pai, nu am comparat-o noi, au facut-o nemtii. Sau Skoda nu are termeni de comparatie ? O fii vre-o super masina ?


--------------------
Renault Megane Sedan IV Tce 116 2019 Business
User is offlineGalerie FotoPM
Go to the top of the page
+
Arhimede
post 15 Nov 2007, 14:49
Post #13


Membru inferior, lung si tare


Group: Members
Posts: 2.294
Joined: 5 March 05
Da Roomster pe ce platforma e facut?


--------------------
dacia lgn 2005 Ambition
0% avertisment=0% divertisment
User is offlineGalerie FotoPM
Go to the top of the page
+
2dor
post 15 Nov 2007, 14:50
Post #14


Desi nu pare, acum sunt fan iPhone


Group: Members
Posts: 2.827
Joined: 14 April 06
From: Bucuresti
Pentru cine nu stie definitia "prastiei" = naspa, urat, rau de tot.

The ESP free Romanian Underdog with its mix from mode and Clio parts places in professional hand the Skoda in the driving dynamics test coldly. Differently than when driving on the highway, where the Roomster command converts clearly more precisely and the driver - if necessarily - with ESP and anti-slip regulation supports. With the Logan against it own contribution is in demand in critical situations: There is not a favourable price evenly in vain.

This post has been edited by 2dor: 15 Nov 2007, 14:54


--------------------
Ford Mondeo Vignale Hybrid 2018
Be nimble as a greyhound, as tough as leather, as hard as Krupp steel and so you shall be the German warrior incarnate.
User is offlineGalerie FotoPM
Go to the top of the page
+
b76bgaarh
post 15 Nov 2007, 14:53
Post #15


Membru autentic


Group: Members
Posts: 9.966
Joined: 5 October 06
From: Bucuresti
roomster este pe platforma de fabia 2

15 Nov 2007, 15:54:
QUOTE(2dor @ 15 Nov 2007, 15:32)
Bine ca acum am ajuns sa comparam Skoda cu Dacia. radmasa.gif
*




de ce sa nu comparam marca ieftina de la VAG cu marca ieftina de la reno???

This post has been edited by b76bgaarh: 15 Nov 2007, 14:54


--------------------
Renault Megane sedan 04/2007 1,5 dci 85 cp ZEFI
Realme GT2 Neo cu here, maps, viamichelin, waze.
User is offlineGalerie FotoPM
Go to the top of the page
+
lucian_v
post 15 Nov 2007, 14:57
Post #16


Membru autentic


Group: Members
Posts: 543
Joined: 13 December 03
From: Bucuresti
QUOTE(Amedeus @ 15 Nov 2007, 14:47)
Pai, nu am comparat-o noi, au facut-o nemtii. Sau Skoda nu are termeni de comparatie ? O fii vre-o super masina ?
*



Nu e o supermasina dar nici nu se coboara la nivelul daciei blush.gif


--------------------
--- --- - --- ---
User is offlineGalerie FotoPM
Go to the top of the page
+
2dor
post 15 Nov 2007, 14:59
Post #17


Desi nu pare, acum sunt fan iPhone


Group: Members
Posts: 2.827
Joined: 14 April 06
From: Bucuresti
Pai ca nu o sa fie niciodata o comparatie intre Skoda si Dacia, poate nu stii dar Skoda Superb este mai luxoasa decat un Passat, nu prea mai e Skoda marca ieftina a lui VW, mai ales ca cehii trag tare si cam fac masini fiabile, in schimb VW cam a dat-o pe brazda.

This post has been edited by 2dor: 15 Nov 2007, 15:00


--------------------
Ford Mondeo Vignale Hybrid 2018
Be nimble as a greyhound, as tough as leather, as hard as Krupp steel and so you shall be the German warrior incarnate.
User is offlineGalerie FotoPM
Go to the top of the page
+
b76bgaarh
post 15 Nov 2007, 15:00
Post #18


Membru autentic


Group: Members
Posts: 9.966
Joined: 5 October 06
From: Bucuresti
tudor da-mi voie sa worship.gif


--------------------
Renault Megane sedan 04/2007 1,5 dci 85 cp ZEFI
Realme GT2 Neo cu here, maps, viamichelin, waze.
User is offlineGalerie FotoPM
Go to the top of the page
+
Arhimede
post 15 Nov 2007, 15:01
Post #19


Membru inferior, lung si tare


Group: Members
Posts: 2.294
Joined: 5 March 05
Si fabia 2 vine pe aceiasi platforma cu primul model.Nimic schimbat.


--------------------
dacia lgn 2005 Ambition
0% avertisment=0% divertisment
User is offlineGalerie FotoPM
Go to the top of the page
+
IRONICK
post 15 Nov 2007, 15:03
Post #20


-


Group: Members
Posts: 22.771
Joined: 19 April 05
From: Romania
QUOTE(Amedeus @ 15 Nov 2007, 15:47)
O fii vre-o super masina ?
pe langa emceveu chiar este masina. Nu neaparat si din prisma diferentei de pret. Daca le-am da celor de la Skoda si Renault un pret si le-am zice sa construiasca o masina, cei la Skoda or sa foloseasca solutii mai scumpe.

This post has been edited by IRONICK: 15 Nov 2007, 15:09


--------------------
CUGIR Albalux 11 - B-11-LUX 1982
User is offlineGalerie FotoPM
Go to the top of the page
+
2dor
post 15 Nov 2007, 15:05
Post #21


Desi nu pare, acum sunt fan iPhone


Group: Members
Posts: 2.827
Joined: 14 April 06
From: Bucuresti
QUOTE(b76bgaarh @ 15 Nov 2007, 16:00)
tudor da-mi voie sa  worship.gif
*



Sorry dar nu mai am locuri disponibile pentru discipoli.

This post has been edited by 2dor: 15 Nov 2007, 15:06


--------------------
Ford Mondeo Vignale Hybrid 2018
Be nimble as a greyhound, as tough as leather, as hard as Krupp steel and so you shall be the German warrior incarnate.
User is offlineGalerie FotoPM
Go to the top of the page
+
b76bgaarh
post 15 Nov 2007, 15:09
Post #22


Membru autentic


Group: Members
Posts: 9.966
Joined: 5 October 06
From: Bucuresti
imi pare rau...dar eu sunt disponibil doar la cineva de la care chiar am ceva de invatat....


--------------------
Renault Megane sedan 04/2007 1,5 dci 85 cp ZEFI
Realme GT2 Neo cu here, maps, viamichelin, waze.
User is offlineGalerie FotoPM
Go to the top of the page
+
2dor
post 15 Nov 2007, 15:12
Post #23


Desi nu pare, acum sunt fan iPhone


Group: Members
Posts: 2.827
Joined: 14 April 06
From: Bucuresti
Totusi chiar nu am locuri, nu pot sa fac exceptie pentru tine...


--------------------
Ford Mondeo Vignale Hybrid 2018
Be nimble as a greyhound, as tough as leather, as hard as Krupp steel and so you shall be the German warrior incarnate.
User is offlineGalerie FotoPM
Go to the top of the page
+
Bliss
post 15 Nov 2007, 15:13
Post #24


-


Group: Members
Posts: 937
Joined: 10 July 06
QUOTE(2dor @ 15 Nov 2007, 15:59)
poate nu stii dar Skoda Superb este mai luxoasa decat un Passat

Sula cu prefectura. De Phaeton ai auzit?
QUOTE
nu prea mai e Skoda marca ieftina a lui VW, mai ales ca cehii trag tare si cam fac masini fiabile, in schimb VW cam a dat-o pe brazda.

Adica si la VAG se mai strica masinile?! Incredibil, dom'le.

De acord cu ssilviu, Logan-ul are un raport value/money mult mai bun decat Roomster. Iar Skoda are plusuri care se reflecta in pret. Care-i marea nedreptate facuta de nemti?


--------------------
- - -
User is offlineGalerie FotoPM
Go to the top of the page
+
2dor
post 15 Nov 2007, 15:19
Post #25


Desi nu pare, acum sunt fan iPhone


Group: Members
Posts: 2.827
Joined: 14 April 06
From: Bucuresti
[quote=Bliss,15 Nov 2007, 16:13]
Sula cu prefectura. De Phaeton ai auzit?

Ideea era ca Skoda Superb e aceiasi masina cu VW Passat insa e mai lunga si mai luxoasa.


--------------------
Ford Mondeo Vignale Hybrid 2018
Be nimble as a greyhound, as tough as leather, as hard as Krupp steel and so you shall be the German warrior incarnate.
User is offlineGalerie FotoPM
Go to the top of the page
+
IRONICK
post 15 Nov 2007, 15:34
Post #26


-


Group: Members
Posts: 22.771
Joined: 19 April 05
From: Romania
QUOTE(Bliss @ 15 Nov 2007, 16:13)
De acord cu ssilviu, Logan-ul are un raport value/money mult mai bun decat Roomster.
Faptul ca este mai ieftina si mai mare nu inseamna ca are un raport mai bun.


--------------------
CUGIR Albalux 11 - B-11-LUX 1982
User is offlineGalerie FotoPM
Go to the top of the page
+
vis-a-vis
post 15 Nov 2007, 15:37
Post #27


DaciaClubber


Group: Members
Posts: 7.893
Joined: 20 June 05
From: Bucuresti
QUOTE(2dor @ 15 Nov 2007, 16:19)
QUOTE(Bliss @ 15 Nov 2007, 16:13)

Sula cu prefectura. De Phaeton ai auzit?


Ideea era ca Skoda Superb e aceiasi masina cu VW Passat insa e mai lunga si mai luxoasa.
*

Asta pana apare Skoda SuperSuperb... derivat din Phaeton tongue.gif

This post has been edited by vis-a-vis: 15 Nov 2007, 15:38


--------------------
Dacia Logan MCV 1.5 DCi
Life is a journey, not a destination.
User is offlineGalerie FotoPM
Go to the top of the page
+
Puiu Tabara
post 15 Nov 2007, 15:38
Post #28


Membru incepator


Group: Members
Posts: 54
Joined: 28 November 04
From: Oradea, Timisoara
Eu zic ca articolul este, din nou (a se aduce aminte de testul elanului) foarte relevant si obiectiv, doar ca nu spune cate unitati a vandut Dacia la nemti si cate Skoda, sau asta o fi sursa articolului?? wacko.gif wacko.gif


--------------------
dacia logan ambition - bh-04-yek
User is offlineGalerie FotoPM
Go to the top of the page
+
Bliss
post 15 Nov 2007, 15:54
Post #29


-


Group: Members
Posts: 937
Joined: 10 July 06
QUOTE(IRONICK @ 15 Nov 2007, 16:34)
Faptul ca este mai ieftina si mai mare nu inseamna ca are un raport mai bun.

Cand nu ai aia mii de iepuroi diferenta pentru chestii care poate-ti sunt indiferente, e raportul ideal. Personal, daca as avea bani ficsi pentru Roomster, mi-as lua Logan. Restul i-as baga in motorina si m-as plimba prin toata tara, sa o vad de la un capat la altul.
QUOTE(2dor)
Ideea era ca Skoda Superb e aceiasi masina cu VW Passat insa e mai lunga si mai luxoasa.

Cu 10 cm. Si daca o Skoda Superb e luxoasa, cum mama ciorilor o mai fi un RR Phantom. Luxul adevarat intr-o masina n-o sa-l gasesti sub 100.000 EUR, oricat le-ar placea unora fara atatia bani sa creada.

Noi sa fim sanatosi. Pana una alta, pe strazi sunt mult mai multe MCV-uri decat Roomstere.


--------------------
- - -
User is offlineGalerie FotoPM
Go to the top of the page
+
IRONICK
post 15 Nov 2007, 15:57
Post #30


-


Group: Members
Posts: 22.771
Joined: 19 April 05
From: Romania
QUOTE(Bliss @ 15 Nov 2007, 16:54)
Cand nu ai aia mii de iepuroi diferenta pentru chestii care poate-ti sunt indiferente, e raportul ideal. Personal, daca as avea bani ficsi pentru Roomster, mi-as lua Logan. Restul i-as baga in motorina si m-as plimba prin toata tara, sa o vad de la un capat la altul.
Mai bine sa mergi cu ea, decat sa strangi din cur ca sa platesti ratele sau ceva de genul asta. Pentru genul asta de oameni este masina cu raport bun pret/calitate. Este doar o masina de care te folosesti de ea. Nu iti ofera absolut nici o placere a condusului.

This post has been edited by IRONICK: 15 Nov 2007, 16:17


--------------------
CUGIR Albalux 11 - B-11-LUX 1982
User is offlineGalerie FotoPM
Go to the top of the page
+
« Next Oldest · Cafenea · Next Newest »
 
2 Pages  1 2 >
 Reply to this topic Topic OptionsStart new topic
Forum Renault Romania - Renault Club Romania
Random Picture Google search Last addition
Imagine aleatoare
căutare personalizată
Ultima imagine adaugata

1 User(s) are reading this topic (1 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)
0 Members:
 

> Reno.ro - Forum Renault Romania > Alte discutii > Cafenea
Lo-Fi Version  Harta site  Parteneri  Jocuri online  Curs Valutar  HRH Haine din lana merinos Time is now: 31st July 2025 - 17:06
Invision Power Board © 2025  IPS, Inc.
Licensed to: DaciaClub - Reno.ro
Dacia